Choice One Roofing and Exteriors
Roof Replacement — Northeast Ohio

A new roof, done right, in a day.

When repair is no longer the smart money, we replace your roof with materials built for Ohio weather — and most re-roofs are finished, inspected, and cleaned up in a single day.

Request a Free Inspection (330) 688-7663
What’s included

Roof Replacement, handled completely.

A roof replacement is the biggest exterior decision most homeowners ever make — and the place where corner-cutting hides best, because everything wrong is covered up by 3 PM. We built our reputation on doing the invisible parts right: full tear-off, decking repairs, ice and water shield where Ohio winters demand it, and ventilation that protects your shingle warranty.

Our installation crews are local Amish craftsmen who have built and roofed in this region for generations. That’s why most of our re-roofs are finished — and the site completely cleaned up — in a single day, without the quality trade-off that usually implies.

If your replacement is storm-related, we handle the insurance claim end to end. Many of our customers pay little more than their deductible.

  • Full tear-off down to the decking — no shortcuts over old shingles
  • Decking inspection with rotten boards replaced before anything goes on top
  • Architectural shingles rated for Ohio wind, hail, and freeze-thaw cycles
  • Ice and water shield, synthetic underlayment, and proper ridge ventilation
  • Complete same-day cleanup with magnetic nail sweep of your yard and drive
  • Workmanship warranty on top of the manufacturer’s shingle warranty

Signs you need a replacement, not a repair

  • Your roof is 18+ years old, or neighbors with same-age homes are replacing theirs
  • Shingles are curling, cracking, or losing granules into the gutters
  • You can see dark streaks, sagging lines, or daylight in the attic
  • A storm came through and your yard had shingle pieces in it
  • You’re planning to sell — a new roof is one of the highest-ROI exterior upgrades

We work with every major insurance carrier

State FarmUSAAFarmersAmerican FamilySafecoFarm BureauTravelersProgressiveMercuryLiberty MutualHartfordNational GeneralAAAAllstateNationwideAuto OwnersAmicaGeicoUniversal InsuranceCSIState FarmUSAAFarmersAmerican FamilySafecoFarm BureauTravelersProgressiveMercuryLiberty MutualHartfordNational GeneralAAAAllstateNationwideAuto OwnersAmicaGeicoUniversal InsuranceCSI

Don’t see yours? These are just a few of the carriers we work with — ask us.

Answers

Roof Replacement — common questions

How much does a roof replacement cost in Ohio?
It depends on the size and pitch of your roof, the material you choose, and how much decking needs to be replaced underneath — so any number over the phone is a guess. Most Northeast Ohio asphalt-shingle replacements fall into a wide range depending on those factors, and if the damage is storm-related many homeowners pay little more than their insurance deductible. The honest way to get a real number is a free on-site inspection, and we give you the itemized figure in writing.
What are the signs you need a new roof instead of a repair?
The usual signs are a roof that is 18+ years old, shingles that are curling, cracking, or shedding granules into the gutters, dark streaks or sagging rooflines, daylight visible in the attic, or shingle pieces in the yard after a storm. If several of those are true at once, a replacement is usually the smarter money than a repair. We tell you honestly which one your roof actually needs.
Are Amish roofing contractors in Ohio actually better?
Our installation crews are local Amish craftsmen who have built and roofed in Northeast Ohio for generations. The advantage is workmanship and speed without cutting corners — it is why most of our re-roofs are finished, and the site completely cleaned up, in a single day. Every job still carries our workmanship warranty on top of the manufacturer shingle warranty.
Metal roof vs. shingles — which is better for Ohio weather?
Both work well here. Architectural asphalt shingles are the most cost-effective choice, rated for Ohio wind, hail, and freeze-thaw, and are what most homeowners choose. A metal roof costs more up front but lasts longer and sheds snow well. We walk you through the trade-offs for your specific home rather than pushing one product.

More ways we can help

Roof Repair

Roof Repair

Leaks, missing shingles, flashing, and emergency repairs — diagnosed free, fixed fast.

Learn more
Storm Damage

Storm Damage

Wind, hail, and fire damage restoration with 24/7 emergency response.

Learn more
Commercial Roofing

Commercial Roofing

Flat and pitched commercial systems for business owners and property managers.

Learn more
Call Now Free Inspection